Henry 'Arthur' Wiggen

Michael Moriarty

Bruce Pearson

Robert De Niro

Dutch Schnell

Vincent Gardenia

Joe Jaros

Phil Foster

Holly Wiggen

Heather MacRae

Katie

Ann Wedgeworth

Pearson's Father

Patrick McVey

Horse

Danny Aiello

Ugly

Andrew Jarrell

Tootsie, Hotel switchboard operator

Selma Diamond

Piney Woods

Tom Ligon

Team Owner

Barbara Babcock

Bradley Lord

Marshall Efron

Team Owner

Maurice Rosenfield

Goose Williams

Tom Signorelli

Red Traphagen

Barton Heyman

Perry

Donny Burks

Dego

Hector Elias

Pearson's Father

Pat McVey

Aleck Olson

Nicolas Surovy

Canada

James Donahue

Canada Smith

Jim Donohue

George

Hector Troy

Jonah

Tony Major

Dr. Loftus

Alan Manaon

Tegwar Player

Jack Hollander

Dr. Chambers

Ernesto Gonzales

Tegwar Player

Lou Girolami

Dr. Chambers

Ernesto Gonzalez

Doc Loftus

Alan Manson

Detective

Arnold Kapnick

Dutch's Wife

Jean David

Joe's Wife (as Bea Blau)

Beatrice Manley

Joe's Wife

Bea Blau

Keith Crane

Herb Henry

Bruce's Mother

Dorothy Nuebert

Sid Goldman

Pierrino Mascarino

Bruce's Mother

Dorothy Neubert

Gem

Kaydette Grant

Third Base Coach

Dell Bethel

Bat Boy

Forrest Wynn

Baseball Player

Vince Camuto

Baseball Player

Jeff Sartorius

Baseball Player

Willie Lemmey

Baseball Player

Doug Major

Bat Boy

Forrest Wynne