Zoe/Prairie Dawn

Fran Brill

Gina

Alison Bartlett O'Reilly

Big Bird / Bennett Snerf / Cookie Monster

Caroll Spinney

Linda

Linda Bove

Virginia Virginia / Muppet / Abby Cadabby

Leslie Carrara-Rudolph

Elmo

Ryan Dillon

Mrs. Noodle

Kristin Chenoweth

Elmo / Hoots the Owl / Baby Natasha (voice)

Kevin Clash

Luis Rodriguez

Emilio Delgado

Bert/Grover

Eric Jacobson

Telly Monster / Aloysius Snuffleupagus / Irvine

Martin P. Robinson

Stinky/Murray

Joseph Mazzarino

Mr. Noodle

Bill Irwin

Rosita

Carmen Osbahr

Mr. Noodle

Michael Jeter

Susan

Loretta Lang

Baby Bear/Cookie Monster/Two-Headed Monster

David Rudman

Maria Figueroa Rodriguez

Sonia Manzano

Bert

Frank Oz

Bob Jackson

Bob McGrath

Gordon Robinson

Roscoe Orman

The Count

Matt Vogel

Alan

Alan Muraoka

Nina

Suki Lopez

Charlie

Violet Tinnirello

Gabriela

Desiree Casado

Miles

Imani Patterson

Zoe (voice)

Jennifer Barnhart

Ruthie / Suzie Kabloozie (voice) / Suzie Kabloozie

Ruth Buzzi

Celina

Annette Calud

Aloysius Snuffleupagus

Jerry Nelson

Susan Robinson

Loretta Long

Gordon Robinson

Matt Robinson

Curly Bear / Prairie Dawn (voice)

Stephanie D'Abruzzo

Julia (voice)

Stacey Gordon

Daniela

Fernanda Urdapilleta

Mia

Olivia Perez

Self

Andy Grammer

Antonio

Panchito Gómez

Cate

Cate Elefante