Sabrina Spellman

Melissa Joan Hart

Hilda Spellman

Caroline Rhea

Salem Saberhagen (voice)

Nick Bakay

Zelda Spellman

Beth Broderick

Harvey Kinkle

Nate Richert

Jenny Kelley

Michelle Beaudoin

Libby Chessler

Jenna Leigh Green

Principal Willard Kraft

Martin Mull

Valerie Birkhead

Lindsay Sloane

Brad

Jon Huertas

Guest Star

Edgar Allen Poe IV

John

Christopher Rich

Dreama

China Shavers

Eugene Poole

Paul Feig

Quizmaster

Alimi Ballard

Guest Star

Britney Spears

Mary

Jennifer Butt

Roxie King

Soleil Moon Frye

Josh

David Lascher

Bebe Neuwirth

Mr. Alcerro

Tim Thomerson

Guest Star

Danny Bonaduce

Guest Star

George Wyner

Shop Owner

Joe Ochman

Hook

Robert Bauer

Guest Star

Dennis Bailey

Lydia

Shirley Jones

Morgan Cavanaugh

Elisa Donovan

Guest Star

Paula Abdul

Guest Star

Tara Lipinski

Mrs. Quick

Mary Gross

Powell

Ed Gale

Amanda

Emily Hart

Duke

Dick Van Dyke

Mr. Cornwallis

Tim Bagley

Clerk

Audrey Wasilewski

Guest Star

Jeff Austin

Guest Star

Ivan Borodin

Marie Curie

Pamela Dillman

Sparky

Spencer Belgarian

Guest Star

David Fickas

Teacher

Ross Gottstein

Guest Star

Tom Novak

Nemo

Brian Seeman

Guest Star

Craig Strong

Mark Twain

Drew Wilson

Roland

Phil Fondacaro

Edward

Doug Sheehan

Annabelle

Victoria Jackson

Blackbeard

Mark Blankfield

City Inspector

Robert Noble

Guest Star

Bryan Kirkwood

Guest Star

John Salley

Billy

Paul Blake

Guest Star

Mark Wallace

College Guy

Gabe Carpenter

Shakespeare

David Stifel

Miss Sorecorn

Teresa Parente

Gail

Jacqueline Schultz

Mirror Man

Dennis Lipscomb

Marnie

Essence Atkins

Pierre Curie

Alastair Duncan

Pressburger

Dana Woods

Miles Goodman

Trevor Lissauer

Guest Star

Andy Siegel

Emily Dickinson

Elyse Ashton

Caterer

Louisa Abernathy

Guest Star

Daniel Hansen

Bennie

Jimm Giannini

Guest Star

Steve Daniels

Guest Star

Eboni-Keiannia Haynes

Guest Star

Nancy Lanari

Guest Star

Brandie Rocci

Guest Star

Jamie Torcellini

Colette

Ginger Williams

Jedediah

Richard Riehle

Daniel Boone

Matt Battaglia

Guest Star

Billy Blanks

Gretchen

Nicole Nieth

Guest Star

Ed McMahon

Guest Star

Eric Jungmann

Guest Star

Jorge Pallo

French Hen

Mary Bogue

Guest Star

Amy Landers

Guest Star

Zach Selwyn

Custodian

Jerry Hauck

Lion Scout

Brandon Kaplan

John

Jordan Belfi

Guest Star

Mary Goldman

Student

Kasie Kelly

Guest Star

Gerry Lock

Guest Star

Vincent Schiavelli

Pedestrian

Tom Fahn

Guest Star

Jeremy Maxwell

Guest Star

Faith Salie

Guest Star

Chip Chinnery

Guest Star

Mark Colson

Guest Star

Harry S. Murphy

Folk Singer

Lennie Freidman

Young Mr. Kraft

Will Jennings