Deputy Travis Junior

Robert Ben Garant

Lieutenant Jim Dangle

Thomas Lennon

Deputy Trudy Wiegel

Kerri Kenney-Silver

Deputy Raineesha Williams

Niecy Nash

Deputy S. Jones

Cedric Yarbrough

Sergeant Jack Declan

Ian Roberts

Deputy James Garcia

Carlos Alazraqui

Deputy Frank Rizzo

Joe Lo Truglio

Deputy Clementine Johnson

Wendi McLendon-Covey

Guest Star

Bob Herron

Levon French

Craig Robinson

Jillet-Ben Coe

Patton Oswalt

Cow Man

Keegan Michael-Key

Daniel Shaheen

Jonah Hill

Nighthawk

Brandon Molale

Mayor Hernandez

George Lopez

Cap'n Crabby's Manager

Neil Campbell

Inmate Andy

Jim Woods

Camerlingo Frederico

Hal Rudnick

Teacher 2 / Wellness Check Man / State Doctor

Alex Fernie

Big Mike

Toby Huss

Kat Kat

Debra Ling

Guest Star

Mindy Sterling

Deputy Cherisha Kimball

Mary Birdsong

Ice Cream Party Dad

Robert Covarrubias

Guest Star

Alex Berg

Orderly

George Sharperson

Jesus

Seth Morris

Guest Star

Kulap Vilaysack

Warden

Joshua Funk

Patient

Will McLaughlin

Jewlery Store Clerk

Aflamu Johnson

Gary G. Werner

Scott Thompson

The Amazing Ronaldo

Mel Cowan

Guest Star

Todd Fasen

Tour Guide

Danielle Schneider

Drug Dealer

Lobo Sebastian

Crazy White Lady / Karen / Teacher 1

Jenny Robertson

Coach Brad Petrie

Andrew Daly

Leslie Frost / Dance Instructor

Dave Holmes

Guest Star

Eddie Pepitone

Mary Magdalene

Joy Somers

Terry Bernadino

Nick Swardson

Old Man Jeffers

Miles Stroth

Don Bronzoni

Robert Costanzo

Guest Star

Eric Price

Miss Uecker

Carmen Electra

Carmen

Sarah Tiana

Transvestits Hooker

Minnie Goode

Judas

Dew Difonzo Marks

Ranger Glen

Matt Walsh

Debbie Dangle-Frost-Werner

Rachael Harris

Innocent Black Man

Keith Powell

Guest Star

Jane Park Smith

Andrew

Jim Rash

Therapist

Jany Lynch

Principal Mankerville

Kristina Hayes

Chupi Chupi

Jesse Camacho

Guest Star

Kirk Fox

Gary the Proud Boy

Chris Tallman

Bachelorette / Personal Trainer / Van Occupant 1

Cathy Shim

Guest Star

Nick Kroll

Cop Fan

Matt Jones

Car Wash Girl

Carrie Wiita

Car Surfing Kid

James Pumphrey

Brakeless Passenger

Lisa Dempsey

Tree Sitter

Dave Hill

Guest Star

Kyle Dunnigan

Gloria

Jill-Michele Melean

Creepy Pete

Steve Little

Guest Star

Jessie Camacho

Burglar

Tommy Rosales

Cindy

Wanru Tseng

Miss Mertz / Time Traveler / Hatzolah Captain

Michael Ian Black

Sparks Department Captain Miller

Matt Besser

Neighborhood Watch Lady

Julie Brister

Sparks Department Deputy Cooper

Billy Merritt

Oxy Patient / Mr. Meemees / Froggy

Jay Pichardo

Driver / Doctor / Crazy White Lady's Accomplice

Gary Anthony Williams

Terrified Child 2 / Ollie / Oliver Junior Deputy

Oliver Lennon

Steve Marmella / Maitre D'

Jack Plotnick

Scared Straight Kid 2 / Drone Girl / Terrified Child 1

Abigail Garant

Fireman

Mitch Rouse

Widower / Creepy Clown

Ken Marino

Van Occupant 3

Chris Denison

Firecracker Teen / Perp

Zac Oyama

Van Occupant 4

David Lincoln

Wife

Deborah Tarica

Hatzolah Competitor

Jush Allen

Bride

Patty Guggenheim

Lieutenant Donna Fritzgibbons

Jamie Lee Curtis

Nuge

'Weird Al' Yankovic