Jim

Jim Gaffigan

Jeannie Gaffigan

Ashley Williams

Dave

Adam Goldberg

Daniel

Michael Ian Black

Father Nicholas

Tongayi Chirisa

Guest Star

Will Ferrell

Guest Star

Macaulay Culkin

MC

Ted Alexandro

Blanca

Vanessa Aspillaga

Little Mike Gaffigan

Angus Costello

Himself

Alec Baldwin

Stevie

Ann Harada

Himself

Neil deGrasse Tyson

Teenage Mitch

Drew Beasley

Guest Star

John Mulaney

Himself

Dave Attell

Guest Star

Timothy Cardinal Dolan

Guest Star

Carrot Top

Herself

Mia Alvar

Little Jimmy

Jack Gaffigan

Female Security Guard

Catrina Ganey

Himself

Doug Benson

Himself

Greer Barnes

Gaffigan Cave Mom

Jeannie Gaffigan

Guest Star

Nickelback

Bravo Exec

Katlyn Carlson

Himself

Chris Hardwick

Karen Bergreen

Karen Bergreen

Gloria

Melissa Errico

Guest Star

Mario Batali

Himself

Todd Barry

Himself

Daniel Adair

Casting Assistant

Jeanna De Waal

Ana

Irma-Estel Laguerre

Herself

Rivka Galchen

Teenage Pam

Marre Gaffigan

Judge Judy Gold

Judy Gold

Himself

Lewis Dodley

Guest Star

Kelly Ripa

Barista/Franz

Annie Chang

Hector

Rigoberto Garcia

Little Mitch

Liam Keenan

Himself

Luis Gomez

Writer

Carla Duren

Himself

Gilbert Gottfried

Grace

Cadden Jones

James

Wolfgang Jackson Lacz

Male Comedian

Zach Cherry

Jesus

Eric Whitten

Dick Kijek

Wass Stevens

Himself

Perez Hilton

Jeffy

Pete Davidson

Nerdy Girl

Jen Jacob

Construction Guy

H. Foley

Mike Jr.

Sam McCarthy

Himself

Chad Kroeger

Bart

Gregory Haney

Teenage Kathy

Bridget McGarry

Little Jeannie

Nora Murphy

Amanda

Ana Fabrega

Receptionist/Handmaiden

Bisserat Tseggai

Himself

Christian Finnegan

Delivery Guy

Raymond J. Lee

Nerd Guy Fan

Liam McEneaney

Himself

Mike Kroeger

Elizabeth Gaffigan

Caitlin Moeller

Young Guy

Moses Ntekereze

Trevor

Ash McNair

Producer

Warren Katz

Pistachio

Jo Firestone

Little Joe

Carson Hayes Pacheco

Himself

Jerry Seinfeld

Himself

Artie Lange

Herself

Jena Friedman

Mary

Cameron Seely

Himself

Jay Oakerson

Bailiff Monroe

Monroe Martin

Angry Woman

Raquel Bailey

Old Lady

Barbara Malley

Himself

Dave Hill

Mitch

Andy Richter

Lawyer

Adrian Martinez

Teenage Jim

Aidan John Doran

Bearded Guy

Alexander Khait

Young Woman

Gabrielle Ryan

Himself

Zachary Quinto

Gomez

Tig Notaro

Priest

Dan Entriken

Himself

Kelefa Sanneh

Himself

Tyler Oakley

St. Peter

Barry D. Godin

Mindy

Keilly McQuail

Herself

Raven-Symone

Himself

Calvin Trillin

Casting Agent

Deborah Offner

Little Daniel

Graydon Yosowitz

Booker

Conor Perkins

Himself

Colin Quinn

Himself

Malcolm Gladwell

Blogger Juror

Sara Benincasa