Jim

Jim Gaffigan

Jeannie Gaffigan

Ashley Williams

Dave

Adam Goldberg

Daniel

Michael Ian Black

Father Nicholas

Tongayi Chirisa

Dr. Weiss

Fred Armisen

Guest Star

Macaulay Culkin

Ted

Ted Alexandro

Angel

José Álvarez

Dave Attell

Dave Attell

Sheri

Carly Aquilino

Mrs. Keveny

Charlotte Booker

Blanca

Vanessa Aspillaga

Amelia

Michelle Buteau

María Celeste Arrarás

María Celeste Arrarás

Fairchild

Claro Austria

Cop

Mike Britt

Hannibal Buress

Hannibal Buress

Susie

Jade Catta-Preta

Marcus

Brett Azar

Danny

Daniel Collins

Carl

Ken Forman

Kevin

Jon Benjamin

Roxie

Elizabeth A. Davis

Comedy Club MC

Jimmy Failla

Hector

Rigoberto Garcia

Lydia

Victoria Hale

Receptionist

Marcella Lowery

Bausch

Matt Higgins

Vince

Mario D'Leon

Janelle

Marina Franklin

Chloe

Abigail Hawk

Karen

Karen Bergreen

James

Wolfgang Jackson Lacz

Eve

Janeane Garofalo

Mika Brzezinski

Mika Brzezinski

Maria

Meghann Fahy

Elizabeth Gaffigan

Caitlin Moeller

Airport Security Guard

Kevin Hearn Cutts

Nai Nai Chow

Wai Ching Ho

Jim Cramer

Jim Cramer

Pam

Jessica Kirson

Art

Larry Pine

Waiter

Zach Fischer

Mariska Hargitay

Mariska Hargitay

Herself

Lea DeLaria

Mary

Cameron Seely

Himself

Lewis Dodley

Esther Ku

Esther Ku

Doctor

Nicole Shalhoub

Yann

Yaron Urbas

Woman in Park

Yamaneika Saunders

Bowie

Lucian Middleton

Man Two

Rich Duva

Ron Hubb

Jimmy Palumbo

Gigi

Tashiana Washington

Mary

Maisie Sexton

Judy Gold

Judy Gold

Terence

Tony White

Nancy Grace

Nancy Grace

Cory

Robert Smigel

Older Woman

Lorraine Serabian

Man

Gregory Haney

Zoe

Korinne Tetlow

Brooke

Emilea Wilson

Man Three

Josh Hemphill

Cabbie

Ebrahim Jaffer

YMCA Lifeguard

Bryan Winston

Crystal

Elana Justin

Don Lemon

Don Lemon

Rachel Maddow

Rachel Maddow

Betty

Johnnie Mae

Woman in Audience

Dawn McGee

Penny

Angela Muto

Olivia

Elizabeth Noth

Lawrence O'Donnell

Lawrence O'Donnell

Keith Olbermann

Keith Olbermann

Himself

Chris Rock

Joe Scarborough

Joe Scarborough

Mrs. Gagliano

Letty Serra

Special Appearance

Jon Stewart

Jake Tapper

Jake Tapper

Lizz Winstead

Lizz Winstead