Doug Heffernan

Kevin James

Carrie Heffernan

Leah Remini

Deacon Palmer

Victor Williams

Arthur Spooner

Jerry Stiller

Guest Star

Sam McMurray

Spence Olchin

Patton Oswalt

Guest Star

Chris Elliott

Guest Star

William Hurt

Guest Star

Marla Gibbs

Guest Star

Gavin MacLeod

Guest Star

Eddie Money

Hector / Rico

Angelo Pagan

Danny Heffernan

Gary Valentine

Guest Star

Lenny Wolpe

Guest Star

Peter Scolari

Father McAndrew

Joe Flaherty

Guest Star

Ben Stiller

Janet Heffernan

Jenny O'Hara

Joe Heffernan

Dakin Matthews

Guest Star

Christen Nelson

Doug Pruzan

Alex Skuby

Guest Star

Michael Blieden

Guest Star

Randy Kovitz

Guest Star

Tyler Hendrickson

Guest Star

Brandy Lopez

Guest Star

Sam Pancake

Holly Shumpert / Marilyn

Nicole Sullivan

Guest Star

Susie Essman

Guest Star

Tim Matheson

Guest Star

Frantz Turner

Lou Ferrigno

Lou Ferrigno

Guest Star

Angelle Brooks

Leonard / Clerk / Owen

Bobby Divito

Guest Star

Inny Clemons

Guest Star

Benjamin John Parrillo

Guest Star

Nick Toth

Guest Star

Madison Lanc

Guest Star

Michael Kostroff

Guest Star

Jane Lynch

Guest Star

Sharon Madden

Mr. Kaufman / Mr. Kaplan

Victor Raider-Wexler

Guest Star

Robert Catrini

Guest Star

Jan Claire

Guest Star

Iris Bahr

Guest Star

Maurice Smith

Guest Star

Rebecca Metz

Guest Star

Victor Raid-Wexler

Guest Star

Gary Sullivan

Guest Star

Angee Hughes

Guest Star

James Wellington

Guest Star

Zilah Mendoza

Guest Star

Shannon Burwell

Guest Star

Diane Mizota

Guest Star

Jacqueline Aries

Guest Star

Jason Azikiwe

Guest Star

Sharon Brathwaite

Guest Star

Steven Rozic

Guest Star

Mike Washlake

Guest Star

Erik Sullivan

Guest Star

Emily Kuroda

Gloria / Waitress / Allison Finnegan

Amy Stiller

Guest Star

Nick Benson

Guest Star

Tim Valentine

Guest Star

Jon Wellner

Guest Star

Jeff Bowser

Guest Star

Tyler Cole Malinger

Phil / Mel / Coach Wallace

Mookie Barker

Guest Star

Steve O'Connor

Guest Star

Michael Crider

Guest Star

Julie Mullen

Guest Star

Christine Romeo

Guest Star

Katherine Disque

Guest Star

Timmy Deters

Guest Star

Sandra Lee Gimpel

Guest Star

Ken Kerman

Guest Star

Lisa Long

Guest Star

Alex Dodd

Guest Star

Ossie Maier

Guest Star

Nicole Matheson

Richie Iannucci

Larry Romano

Kirby Palmer

Marshaun Daniel

Guest Star

Jon Curry

Guest Star

Mark Withers

Guest Star

Christine Gonzales

Vince / Jimmy / Pool Player

Jackie Flynn

Guest Star

Rob Evors

Guest Star

Anthony Albano

Guest Star

Robert Vincenti

Guest Star

Kevin Schmidt

Guest Star

Frankie Ryan

Guest Star

Steffiana De La Cruz

Guest Star

Nina Weithorn

Kelly Palmer

Merrin Dungey

Guest Star

Alan Heitz

Guest Star

Melissa Chan*

Guest Star

Steve Tancora

Guest Star

Bobby DeVito

Guest Star

Christopher Gehrman

Guest Star

Kaitlyn Gainer

Guest Star

Megan Holloway