Doug Heffernan

Kevin James

Carrie Heffernan

Leah Remini

Arthur Spooner

Jerry Stiller

Deacon Palmer

Victor Williams

Guest Star

Huey Lewis

Spence Olchin

Patton Oswalt

Guest Star

Carol Mansell

Janet Heffernan

Jenny O'Hara

Danny Heffernan

Gary Valentine

Guest Star

Chris Elliott

Father McDaniel / Theatre Usher / Sports Announcer (voice)

Nick Bakay

Guest Star

John Getz

Guest Star

Jim Haynie

Guest Star

Sam McMurray

Guest Star

Arlene Golonka

Guest Star

Mindy Sterling

Guest Star

Michele Nordin

Lou Ferrigno

Lou Ferrigno

Guest Star

Adam West

Jimmy / Jimmy Shubert

Jimmy Shubert

Guest Star

Mindy Spence

Guest Star

Thomas Mills

Guest Star

Kirstie Alley

Guest Star

Sanya Mateyas

Guest Star

Mike Socci

Guest Star

Hayes MacArthur

Holly Shumpert / Marilyn

Nicole Sullivan

Kelly Palmer

Merrin Dungey

Guest Star

Ray Romano

Guest Star

Carla Ferrigno

Guest Star

Charlotte Rae

Guest Star

Neil Sedaka

George Barksdale

Gerry Black

Phil / Mel / Coach Wallace

Mookie Barker

Guest Star

Steve Franken

Guest Star

Laura Silverman

Vince / Jimmy / Pool Player

Jackie Flynn

Kyle / Sam / Security Guard #1

Richie Minervini

Guest Star

Kerry Aissa

Guest Star

Omari Lyles

Guest Star

Jim Turner

Guest Star

Mandy June Turpin

Guest Star

Adam Ferrara

Guest Star

James Hong

Guest Star

Robert Goulet

Guest Star

Pat Harrington

Guest Star

Cooper Thornton

Guest Star

Lucille Soong

Guest Star

Jere Burns

Guest Star

Jenna Gering

Guest Star

Robin Lee Noll

Guest Star

John Sterling Carter

Guest Star

James Lancaster

Lisa / Wedding Coordinator / Sharon

Nikki Tyler-Flynn

Gloria / Waitress / Allison Finnegan

Amy Stiller

Guest Star

Blythe Auffarth

Guest Star

Bryan Callen

Richie Ianucci

Larry Romano

Guest Star

Tim Bagley

Flora / Women In Limo / Margaret

Pamela Kosh

Guest Star

Danny Goldman

Guest Star

Michael Merton

Guest Star

Geoffrey Wade

Guest Star

Kelly Hawthorne

Guest Star

Desmond Roberts

Guest Star

Bill A. Jones

Guest Star

Kevin Michael Walsh

Guest Star

Tyler Flynn

Guest Star

Marco Assante

Joe Heffernan

Dakin Matthews

Teacher / Old Guy / Larry

Larry Newman

Guest Star

Weston Nathanson

Guest Star

Peter Breitmayer

Guest Star

Alex Rayfiel

Guest Star

Michael C. Mahon

Guest Star

Mary Matilyn Mouser

Guest Star

Ginger Williams

Guest Star

Jonathon Buono

Guest Star

Carlos Cervantes

Guest Star

Margaret Easley

Guest Star

Shawn Huang

Guest Star

Norma Michaels

Guest Star

David Haydn-Jones

Rick / Patron / Ticket Agent

Jason Packham

Guest Star

Michael Warner

Guest Star

Sheila Shaw

Guest Star

Emil Beheshti

Kirby Palmer

Marshaun Daniel

Doug Pruzan

Alex Skuby

Mr. Kaufman / Mr. Kaplan

Victor Raider-Wexler

Veronica Olchin / Mary Finnegan

Anne Meara

Amy

Christine Gonzales

Mickey

Ford Rainey

Leonard / Clerk / Owen

Bobby Divito

Young Doug

Tyler Hendrickson

Duke

Steve Tancora

Virginia Heffernan / Woman On Cell Phone / Sarah

Peggy Lane

Denise

Rachel Dratch

Stephanie Heffernan

Ricki Lake

Hector / Rico

Angelo Pagan