Dr. William Fall (segment "The Little Black Bag") / Charlie Finnegan

Burgess Meredith

Dr. Glendon / Colonel Archie Dittman (segment "Clean Kills and Other Trophies")

Raymond Massey

Guest Star

Godfrey Cambridge

Guest Star

Shani Wallis

Guest Star

William Windom

Guest Star

Carl Betz

Charlie Wheatland

Leif Erickson

Aunt Ada Burn Quigley / Miss Wattle / Carlotta Acton (segment "The Housekeeper")

Jeanette Nolan

Elaine Latimer (segment "The House") / The Girl with the Hungry Eyes / Rhona Warwick (segment “The Caterpillar”)

Joanna Pettet

Guest Star

Louis Hayward

Guest Star

John Colicos

Host

Rod Serling

Guest Star

Chill Wills

Guest Star

Agnes Moorehead

Guest Star

John Williams

Guest Star

Pat Boone

Rebecca

Rachel Roberts

Guest Star

Barry Brown

Guest Star

Torin Thatcher

Guest Star

Paul Richards

Guest Star

Larry Hagman

Guest Star

Diane Baker

Guest Star

Tom Bosley

Guest Star

Jeff Corey

Guest Star

Bert Convy

Guest Star

Steve Franken

Guest Star

Suzy Parker

Guest Star

Grayson Hall

Guest Star

Henry Silva

Guest Star

Hedley Mattingly

Mavis Goldsmith (segment "Pickman's Model") / Velia Redford (segment "The Dead Man")

Louise Sorel

Guest Star

Phyllis Diller

Guest Star

Jackie Vernon

Cousin Zachariah Ogilvy / Doctor

Alan Napier

Guest Star

Cathleen Cordell

Jonathan (segment "Pamela's Voice") / Randy Miller / Munsch

John Astin

Guest Star

John Randolph

Molly Wheatland / Mrs. Evans / Frances Turchin

Geraldine Page

Guest Star

Michael Blodgett

Guest Star

Al Lewis

Guest Star

Howard Morton

Grant Wilson (segment "Hatred Unto Death") (as Stephen Forrest)

Steve Forrest

Dina Merrill

Pete Tuttle

Cameron Mitchell

Tom Ogilvy

Stuart Whitman

Craig Lowell / David Faulkner

James Farentino

Ann Bolt (segment "Tell David...")

Sandra Dee

Bradley Meredith

Ross Martin

2nd Reporter (segment "The Nature of the Enemy")

Jason Wingreen

The Phantom (segment "Phantom of What Opera?") / Col. Dennis Malloy

Leslie Nielsen

Bennett / Doctor

Kent Smith