Stephen
Louis Hayward
Host
Rod Serling
Rebecca
Rachel Roberts
Emma Brigham (segment "Certain Shadows on the Wall") / Head Witch (segment "Witches' Feast")
Agnes Moorehead
Cousin Zachariah Ogilvy / Doctor (segment "House - With Ghost")
Alan Napier
Ann
Grayson Hall
Munsch / Jonathan (segment "Pamela's Voice")
John Astin
Molly Wheatland / Mrs. Evans
Geraldine Page
Grant Wilson (segment "Hatred Unto Death") (as Stephen Forrest)
Steve Forrest
Elaine Latimer (segment "The House") / The Girl with the Hungry Eyes / Rhona Warwick (segment “The Caterpillar”)
Joanna Pettet
Dina Merrill
Pete Tuttle
Cameron Mitchell
Tom Ogilvy
Stuart Whitman
Velia Redford (segment "The Dead Man") / Mavis Goldsmith (segment "Pickman's Model")
Louise Sorel
Ann Bolt (segment "Tell David...")
Sandra Dee
Bradley Meredith
Ross Martin
Charlie Wheatland
Leif Erickson
Doctor (segment “The Caterpillar”) / Colonel Hymber Masters (segment "The Doll")
John Williams
David Faulkner / Craig Lowell
James Farentino
Miss Beamish (segment "The Housekeeper")
Cathleen Cordell
Charlie Finnegan
Burgess Meredith
Simms (segment "The Nature of the Enemy")
Joseph Campanella
2nd Reporter (segment "The Nature of the Enemy")
Jason Wingreen
Aunt Ada Burn Quigley / Miss Wattle / Carlotta Acton (segment "The Housekeeper")
Jeanette Nolan