Host

Derek Waters

Guest Star

Thomas Middleditch

Gordon Cooper / Fred Rogers / Ernest Thompson Seton

Colin Hanks

King Charles II / Thomas Edison / Jim Bowie

Chris Parnell

Guest Star

Jesse Plemons

Guest Star

Rob Riggle

Guest Star

Rob Corddry

Guest Star

Liev Schreiber

Guest Star

Michael McKean

Host

Steve Berg

Guest Star

Lin-Manuel Miranda

Guest Star

Vanessa Bayer

Guest Star

Elizabeth Olsen

Guest Star

Kyle Mooney

Guest Star

Alia Shawkat

Guest Star

Michael Cera

Guest Star

Kat Dennings

Guest Star

Joe Lo Truglio

— / H.R. Haldeman / General Andrew Jackson

Jack McBrayer

Guest Star

Taylor Schilling

Guest Star

Thomas Lennon

Guest Star

Mae Whitman

Various

Bennie Arthur

Guest Star

Kevin Pollack

Guest Star

John Cho

Guest Star

Busy Phillips

Guest Star

David Koechner

Guest Star

Billie Joe Armstrong

Guest Star

Rachel Bilson

Guest Star

Ed Helms

Guest Star

Aubrey Plaza

Guest Star

Mariah Wilson

Ron Funches

Guest Star

Ken Marino

Various

Maria Blasucci

Guest Star

Alexandra Grey

Guest Star

Samm Levine

D.B. Cooper / Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi / William Clark

Taran Killam

Edward Cope / Meriwether Lewis / James Monroe

Tony Hale

Various

Craig Cackowski

Guest Star

Andrew Rannells

Guest Star

Juno Temple

Guest Star

Sugar Lyn Beard

Guest Star

Allison Tolman

Guest Star

Chris Witaske

Guest Star

Kevin Farley

Guest Star

Dwight Yoakam

Guest Star

Sarah Ramos

Stetson Kennedy / Elisha Gray / Robert Wilson

Jason Ritter

Narrator

Craig Anstett

Guest Star

Louie Anderson

Guest Star

Ben Folds

Guest Star

Josh Charles

Guest Star

Bokeem Woodbine

Various

Jeremy J. Tutson

Guest Star

Brendan Sexton

Guest Star

Patton Oswalt

Guest Star

David Wain

Guest Star

Jenna Fisher

Guest Star

Michaela Watkins

Various

Tymberlee Hill

Narrator

Rich Fulcher

Guest Star

Anthony Edwards

Guest Star

Ronda Rousey

Various

Sarah Burns

Narrator

Phil Hendrie

Guest Star

Dave Grohl

Various

Michael Daniel Cassady

Various

Adam Nee

Vincenzo Peruggia / Elvis Presley / William Mulholland

Jack Black

Ponce De Leon / Marshall Ratliff / Johnny Cash

Johnny Knoxville

Scientist / Rough Rider / Bootlegger

Kyle David Crosby

Various / Fireman

Michael Coleman

Himself - Narrator / Museum Guard

Eric Edelstein

Director

Derek Waters

Director

Jeremy Konner