Rebecca Bunch

Rachel Bloom

Josh Chan

Vincent Rodriguez III

Paula Proctor

Donna Lynne Champlin

Darryl Whitefeather

Pete Gardner

Heather Davis

Vella Lovell

Valencia

Gabrielle Ruiz

Guest Star

Rachel Grate

Nathaniel Plimpton III

Scott Michael Foster

Maya

Esther Povitsky

Guest Star

Nia Vardalos

Guest Star

Cheri Oteri

Hector

Erick Lopez

White Josh

David Hull

Tucker

Luca Padovan

Greg Serrano

Skylar Astin

Greg Serrano

Santino Fontana

Naomi Bunch

Tovah Feldshuh

George

Danny Jolles

Tommy Proctor

Steele Stebbins

Dr. Davit Akopian

Piter Marek

Mrs. Hernandez

Gina Gallego

Brody

Benjamin Siemon

Jasmine

Jully Lee

Chris

Jacob Guenther

Tim Campbell / Tim

Michael McMillian

Hanifa Downey

Kalea McNeill

AJ

Clark Moore

Young Rebecca

Ava Acres

Cybil

Pam Murphy

Judge

Angela Robinson Witherspoon

Dr. Akopian

Michael Hyatt

Drunk Mom

Heather Olt

Mean Prosecutor

Aline Brosh McKenna

Father Brah

Rene Gube

Inmate

Alina Zilbershmidt