Rebecca Bunch

Rachel Bloom

Josh Chan

Vincent Rodriguez III

Greg Serrano

Santino Fontana

Paula Proctor

Donna Lynne Champlin

Darryl Whitefeather

Pete Gardner

Heather Davis

Vella Lovell

Mrs. Hernandez

Gina Gallego

Valencia Perez

Gabrielle Ruiz

Guest Star

Steve Monroe

Karen

Stephnie Weir

Guest Star

Dr. Phil

Dr. Akopian

Michael Hyatt

Guest Star

Tess Paras

Father Brah

Rene Gube

Laura

Isabella Hofmann

Naomi Bunch

Tovah Feldshuh

White Josh

David Hull

Guest Star

B.J. Novak

Guest Star

Cedric Yarbrough

Esther

Patricia Scanlon

Guest Star

Mel Harris

Nathaniel

Scott Michael Foster

Guest Star

Amber Riley

Xander

Thor Knai

Nipsey Hussle

Nipsey Hussle

Kayla

Lulu Antariksa

Lourdes Chan

Amy Hill

Hector

Erick Lopez

Fondue Guy

Nikhil Pai

Guest Star

Ricki Lake

Tommy Proctor

Steele Stebbins

Mexican Lawyer

Johnny Ray Rodriguez

Chris

Jacob Guenther

Super Cheery Camp Girl

Carla Jeffery

Tim Campbell / Tim

Michael McMillian

Girl Playing Nellie

Ashlee Füss

AJ

Clark Moore

Young Rebecca

Ava Acres

Camp Chorus Girl #2

Shanna Strong

Partner #2

Patrick John Hurley

Dancer

Marty Dew

Greg Serrano

Skylar Astin

Dancer

Anthony Marciona

Party patron

Marvin Ryan

Man in Office

Bruce M. Stockert