Jim

Jim Belushi

Cheryl

Courtney Thorne-Smith

Dana Gibson

Kimberly Williams-Paisley

Andy

Larry Joe Campbell

Ruby

Taylor Atelian

Gracie

Billi Bruno

Max

Tom Arnold

Santa / Henry / Phil

Bruce Jarchow

Guest Star

Tim Bagley

Mrs. Nelson

Barbara Dodd Remsen

Alicia

Jennifer Alden

Kyle

Conner Rayburn

Kyle

Owen Pearce

Garret Sullivan

Cindy Devlin

Cynthia Stevenson

Ryan Gibson

Mitch Rouse

Yoki Hirasaki

Suzy Nakamura

Guest Star

Henriette Mantel

Dwayne

Michael Rothhaar

Guest Star

John Rubano

Maggie

Kathleen Noone

Kenny

Ted Michaels

Ashley

Kyle Chavarria

Deliveryman

Willie Amakye

Adult Kyle / Guy No. 2 / Pizza Boy

Robert Belushi

Sheila

Ingrid Sanai Buron

Chip

Chad Brokaw

Saleswoman

Lori Bell

Guest Star

Mark Beltzman

Gwen

Tina Gasbarra

Talia

Nicole Keith

Elf

Tim Kazurinsky

Mr. Farrow

Carlos La Camara

Talia

Nicole Nieth

Old Man

Jack Donner

Waiter

Christopher Stapleton

Police Officer

Charlie Hartsock

Guest Star

Christina Cindrich

Kayak Guy

Christian Anderson

Father

Richard Wilgrubs

Gravedigger

Andrew Hawtrey

Booth Attendant

Amy Brewczynski

Guest Star

Tony Braunagel

Josh Devlin

Sean Hogan

Cajun Man

Thomas Crnkovich

Golfer

Jim Toth

Kid #1

Kurt Doss

Bronko

Mark Brandon Anderson

Brianna

Stacy Stas

Bertram

Steven Gilborn

Dance Instructor

Heather Lee

Speaker

Jamieson Price

Bonnie Beltzman

Jane Morris

Guest Star

Bobby Block

Woman in Strip Club

Carol Pawlak

Kid #2

Benjamin Bryan

Contest Host

Doug Cameron

Guest Star

Renée Ferruggia

Paramedic

Matthew Jones

Reverend Hill

Michael C. McCarthy

Jami / Little Girl / Student #3

Jamison Belushi

Reverend Steven

Anthony Heald

Mandy

Jackie Debatin

Paramedic

Rick Hall

Danny Michalski

Dan Aykroyd

Emily

Mo Collins

Roxanne

Jennifer Coolidge

Laraine Elkin

Laraine Newman

Chad / Eddie

Brad Paisley