Ichabod Crane
Tom Mison
Diana Thomas
Janina Gavankar*
Diana Thomas
Janina Gavankar
Jenny Mills
Lyndie Greenwood
Abbie Mills
Nicole Beharie
Malcolm Dreyfuss
Jeremy Davies
Alex Norwood
Rachel Melvin
Katrina Crane / Katrina Crane (voice)
Katia Winter
Captain Frank Irving
Orlando Jones
Jake Wells
Jerry MacKinnon
Henry Parrish / —
John Noble
Molly Thomas
Oona Yaffe
Jobe
Kamar de los Reyes
Joe Corbin
Zach Appelman
Mr. David
Michael Scialabba
Cop
Jeff Sprauve
Mr. Branson
Griff Furst
Betsy Ross
Nikki Reed
Guest Star
Bill Heck
Guest Star
Robbie Kay
Guest Star
Kelley Missal
Guest Star
Edwin Hodge
Guest Star
Bjorn Dupaty
Security Guard
Ira Carmichael
Geoffrey
Lionel Fine
Daniel Reynolds
Lance Gross
Guest Star
Sara Sanderson
Lara
Seychelle Gabriel
Guest Star
Onira Tares
Eric Cortez
Ace Marrero
Claudia
Claire Byrne
Guest Star
Fedor Steer
Guest Star
Devon Tresan
Parent
Dheeba Donghrer
Carlos
Antoine Williams
Nancy Striker
Catherine Dyer
Pandora
Shannyn Sossamon
Guest Star
Jessejames Locorriere
Guest Star
Rick Espaillat
Guest Star
Samuel Smith
Scarecrow / Horseman of War / Wendigo
Marti Matulis
The Devil
Terrence Mann
Guest Star
Courtney Lakin
Guest Star
Kaiser Johnson
Guest Star
Derrick Lamont
Kendra
Bailey Tippen
Young Boy
Jacob Langa
Lobbyist
Brian Patrick Murphy
Guest Star
Mark Campbell
Guest Star
Brent Glenen
Guest Star
James Kyson
Guest Star
Dayana Rincon
Guest Star
LB Brown
Guest Star
Euseph Messiah
Classy Guy
Sash Morfaw
Young Girl
Jun Ogden
Guest Star
Kathleen Hogan
Guest Star
Yan Feldman
Guest Star
Rey Hernandez
Guest Star
Dawntavia Bullard
Guest Star
Kristen McFann
Staffer
Aaron Smalls
Guest Star
Charles Justo
Classy Girl
Onye Eme-Akwari
Guest Star
Charmin Lee
Guest Star
Jon Stafford
Dude
Michael Ewing
Guest Star
John Zachary
Guest Star
Selena Anduze
Guest Star
Cedric Greenway
Guest Star
John Michael Weatherly
Guest Star
Barry Stoltze
Mary Todd Lincoln
Karen Boles
Bryce
Hayley Lovitt
Guest Star
Samantha Kacho
Soccer Mom
Tara Lee
The Hidden One
Peter Mensah
Guest Star
Joshua Loren
Guest Star
Daryn Kahn
Headless Horseman
Jeremy Owens
The Gentleman
Alexander Ward
Abraham Van Brunt
Neil Jackson
Guest Star
R. Keith Harris
Nick Hawley
Matt Barr
Guest Star
Lawrence Kao
Moloch / Golem
Derek Mears
Guest Star
Tom Archdeacon
Andy Brooks
John Cho
Headless Horseman
Craig Branham
Detective Luke Morales / —
Nicholas Gonzalez
Sheriff August Corbin
Clancy Brown
Cynthia Irving
Jill Marie Jones
Moloch / Blurry Man
D.J. Mifflin
Randall Martin / Sam
Anthony K. Hyatt
Sheriff Leena Reyes
Sakina Jaffrey
Lincoln
John Zachary
Souvenir Seller
Daryn Kahn
Colonial Fan
Dayne Catalano
John Wilkes Booth
Adrian Bond
Infected Hospital Patient
John Gettier
Theater Patron
Beverley Simmons