Ichabod Crane

Tom Mison

Diana Thomas

Janina Gavankar

Jenny Mills

Lyndie Greenwood

Abbie Mills

Nicole Beharie

Malcolm Dreyfuss

Jeremy Davies

Alex Norwood

Rachel Melvin

Katrina Crane / Katrina Crane (voice)

Katia Winter

Captain Frank Irving

Orlando Jones

Jake Wells

Jerry MacKinnon

Henry Parrish / —

John Noble

Molly Thomas

Oona Yaffe

Jobe

Kamar de los Reyes

Joe Corbin

Zach Appelman

Mr. David

Michael Scialabba

Cop

Jeff Sprauve

Mr. Branson

Griff Furst

Betsy Ross

Nikki Reed

Guest Star

Bill Heck

Guest Star

Robbie Kay

Guest Star

Kelley Missal

Guest Star

Edwin Hodge

Guest Star

Bjorn Dupaty

Security Guard

Ira Carmichael

Geoffrey

Lionel Fine

Daniel Reynolds

Lance Gross

Guest Star

Sara Sanderson

Lara

Seychelle Gabriel

Guest Star

Onira Tares

Eric Cortez

Ace Marrero

Claudia

Claire Byrne

Guest Star

Fedor Steer

Guest Star

Devon Tresan

Parent

Dheeba Donghrer

Carlos

Antoine Williams

Nancy Striker

Catherine Dyer

Pandora

Shannyn Sossamon

Guest Star

Jessejames Locorriere

Guest Star

Rick Espaillat

Guest Star

Samuel Smith

Scarecrow / Horseman of War / Wendigo

Marti Matulis

The Devil

Terrence Mann

Guest Star

Courtney Lakin

Guest Star

Kaiser Johnson

Guest Star

Derrick Lamont

Kendra

Bailey Tippen

Young Boy

Jacob Langa

Lobbyist

Brian Patrick Murphy

Guest Star

Mark Campbell

Guest Star

Brent Glenen

Guest Star

James Kyson

Guest Star

Dayana Rincon

Guest Star

LB Brown

Guest Star

Euseph Messiah

Classy Guy

Sash Morfaw

Young Girl

Jun Ogden

Guest Star

Kathleen Hogan

Guest Star

Yan Feldman

Guest Star

Rey Hernandez

Guest Star

Dawntavia Bullard

Guest Star

Kristen McFann

Staffer

Aaron Smalls

Guest Star

Charles Justo

Classy Girl

Onye Eme-Akwari

Guest Star

Charmin Lee

Guest Star

Jon Stafford

Dude

Michael Ewing

Guest Star

John Zachary

Guest Star

Selena Anduze

Guest Star

Cedric Greenway

Guest Star

John Michael Weatherly

Guest Star

Barry Stoltze

Mary Todd Lincoln

Karen Boles

Bryce

Hayley Lovitt

Guest Star

Samantha Kacho

Soccer Mom

Tara Lee

The Hidden One

Peter Mensah

Guest Star

Joshua Loren

Guest Star

Daryn Kahn

Headless Horseman

Jeremy Owens

The Gentleman

Alexander Ward

Abraham Van Brunt

Neil Jackson

Guest Star

R. Keith Harris

Nick Hawley

Matt Barr

Guest Star

Lawrence Kao

Moloch / Golem

Derek Mears

Guest Star

Tom Archdeacon

Andy Brooks

John Cho

Headless Horseman

Craig Branham

Detective Luke Morales / —

Nicholas Gonzalez

Sheriff August Corbin

Clancy Brown

Cynthia Irving

Jill Marie Jones

Moloch / Blurry Man

D.J. Mifflin

Randall Martin / Sam

Anthony K. Hyatt

Sheriff Leena Reyes

Sakina Jaffrey

Colonial Fan

Dayne Catalano

John Wilkes Booth

Adrian Bond

Infected Hospital Patient

John Gettier

Theater Patron

Beverley Simmons