Mary Sibley

Janet Montgomery

John Alden

Shane West

Cotton Mather

Seth Gabel

Tituba

Ashley Madekwe

Anne Hale

Tamzin Merchant

Magistrate Hale

Xander Berkeley

Mercy Lewis

Elise Eberle

Baron Sebastian Marburg

Joe Doyle

Isaac Walton

Iddo Goldberg

Little John

Oliver Bell

Countess Marburg

Lucy Lawless

Samuel Wainwright

Stuart Townsend

The Sentinel

Samuel Roukin

Hathorne

Jeremy Crutchley

Treasurer Putnam

Jonny Coyne

John Sibley/The Devil

Jon Fletcher

Thomas Dinley

Marilyn Manson

Essex Witch

Allyn Carrell

Mrs. Stoughton

Meagen Fay

Mr. Stoughton

Robert Picardo

Naked Dead Body

David Shiflett

Increase Mather

Stephen Lang

Gloriana Embry

Azure Parsons

Militia Leader

Owen Harn

Billy

Emily Skeggs

Alice

Ashlyn Pearce

Corwin

Hank Harris

Adult Slave

Marcus Graves

Nervous Militia Man

James Ricker II

Acolyte

Ashton Smiley

Merchant

Matthew Rimmer

French Commander

Timothy Fall

Refugee Thief

Billy Slaughter

Dead Petrus

Matthew R. Staley

Brutal Brother

Danny Cosmo

Orange Seller

Harlon Miller

Male Witch

Jay Caputo

Night Watchman

Jim Henry

Selectman

Bruce Roberts

Towering Bird Dick Man

Clint James

Elizabeth

Lucy Faust

Blacksmith

Doug Van Liew

Old Woman

Stephanie Dunnam

Townsperson

Lindsey Roberts

Bridget Bishop

Antonia Prebble

Rebecca Nurse

Nadine Lewington

Essex Elder

Morgana Shaw

Selectman

Gregory Nye

Stephen

Braden Fitzgerald

Refugee Woman

Olga Wilhelmine

Night Watchman

Jeremy Summers