Mary Sibley

Janet Montgomery

John Alden

Shane West

Cotton Mather

Seth Gabel

Tituba

Ashley Madekwe

Anne Hale

Tamzin Merchant

Magistrate Hale

Xander Berkeley

Mercy Lewis

Elise Eberle

Isaac Walton

Iddo Goldberg

Rose

Diane Salinger

George Sibley

Michael Mulheren

Giles Corey

Kevin Tighe

Dollie Trask

Sammi Hanratty

Little John

Oliver Bell

Bridget Bishop

Antonia Prebble

Gloriana

Azure Parsons

Petrus

Christopher Berry

Increase Mather

Stephen Lang

William Hooke

Matthew Holmes

Condessa Marburg

Lucy Lawless

Abigail Cook

Alexandra Daniels

Bartender

Rodger Boyce

The Sentry

Brett Baker

Mrs. Hale

Lara Grice

Blacksmith

Kim Collins

Baron Sebastian Marburg

Joe Doyle

Ancient Witch 2

Juli Erickson

Jane Alden

Heather Bloom

Young Hale

Aiden Flowers

Reverend Lewis

J.D. Evermore

Hawker

Mark Ashworth

Gibbering Demon

Michael Robert Brandon

The Sentinel

Samuel Roukin

Middle Aged Woman

Sharon Garrison

Reverend Lewis

Thomas Francis Murphy

Elizabeth

Lucy Faust

Teenage Girl

Caroline Hebert

Mrs. Trask

Rachel Whitman Groves

Sentry

John Jabaley

Naked Dead Body

David Shiflett

Neighbor 2

Melanie Haynes

Puritan

John P. Fertitta

Stephen

Braden Fitzgerald

Selectman

Richard Holden

Dead Body 3

B.J. Grogan

Hannah

Emily Marie Palmer

Joe Barker

Daniel James

Ancient Witch 1

Jennifer Griffin

Undead 1

Jay Caputo

Shaman

J. LaRose

Alice

Juliet Buckholdt

Native American

James R. Frey

Corwin

Hank Harris

Acolyte 2

Amber Dawn Landrum

Captain

David Jensen

Undead 4

Danny Cosmo

Dead Body 1

Linda Leonard

Acolyte

Ashton Smiley

Mrs. Barker

Sharon Landry

Slave Ship Captain

Robert Ousley

Dead Militia/Townsfolk

Josh Davis

Shipping Manager

Garrett Hines

Kitty

Teri Wyble

Militia

Jim Henry

Sibley Servant

Ian Sinclair

Bailiff

Jon Arthur

Lamb

Benjamin Mouton

Elizabeth

Adriana Karras

Mab

Morgana Shaw

Henry Hopkins

Dane Rhodes

Sibley Servant

Sarah Eilts

Militia

W.M. Bacon

Selectman

Bruce Roberts

Isaac's Man

Clint James

Ruffian

John Swider

Militia on horseback

Lance Eakright

Colonel

Terry Milam

Dead Body 2

Christine Tonry

Militia Man

Michael P Gardner

Ancient Witch 1

Peggy Walton-Walker

Nude Corpse 1

Amanda Marie

Drunk in Threesome

Kevin Adams

Dead Man

Cory Patt

Prostitute

Paula Marcenaro Solinger

Dancer

Sheri Davis

Pilgrim Witch Sympathizer

J. Alan Nelson

Flashing Puritan

Michelle Harvey

Laundress Child

Laney Kate Hulbert

Mohawk

David Midthunder

Fur Trader

Joseph Blackstone

Slave

Elizabeth Dukes Melancon

Merchant Child

Mary Hulbert

Sentry

Eric Weiss

Lamb's Publick House Bartender

R. Todd Jones

Selectmen and Orgy Dancer

Michael McCormick

Townsfolk

Kristen M. Mentasti

Puritan

Michele B. McGraw

Puritan

Alice Searcy

Militia/Zombie

Justin Lebrun

Selectman

Gregory Nye

Mohawk

Martin Sensmeier