Mary Sibley

Janet Montgomery

John Alden

Shane West

Cotton Mather

Seth Gabel

Tituba

Ashley Madekwe

Anne Hale

Tamzin Merchant

Mercy Lewis

Elise Eberle

Isaac Walton

Iddo Goldberg

Baron Sebastian Marburg

Joe Doyle

Countess Marburg

Lucy Lawless

Little John

Oliver Bell

Samuel Wainwright

Stuart Townsend

Magistrate Hale

Xander Berkeley

Hathorne

Jeremy Crutchley

Past Countess

Ava Ticotin

Old Witch 1

Allyn Carrell

Dollie Trask

Sammi Hanratty

The Sentinel

Samuel Roukin

The Other Girl

Caroline Delatte

Naked Dead Body

David Shiflett

George Sibley

Michael Mulheren

Corwin

Hank Harris

Drunk in Threesome

Kevin Adams

The Shaman

Raoul Max Trujillo

Old Witch 2

Thomas Herod Jr.

Militia Man

Colton Tapp

Petrus

Christopher Berry

Overseer

Tina Parker

Increase Mather

Stephen Lang

Reverend Lewis

Thomas Francis Murphy

Dead Roman Child

Chance Caeden

Selectman

Gregory Nye

Captain Braun

Miles Doleac

Body Collector

James W. Evermore

Acolyte

Ashton Smiley

Thomas Elliot

Henri Lubatti

Selectman

Bruce Roberts

Farmer

Jim Blumetti

Militiaman

Frank Duffy

Customs Clerk

Ian Hoch

Townsfolk

Jeremy Summers

Militia Man

David Kallaway

Marburg Valet

Christopher Warren

Pox Victim - Deceased

Ashley Turner

Sooleawa

Cara Santana

Elizabeth

Lucy Faust

Bridget Bishop

Antonia Prebble

Nathaniel

Ian Sinclair

Elder Witch 2

Juli Erickson

Widow

Yvonne Landry

Townsperson

Devan Gerlach

Townsperson

Stan Taylor

Acolyte

Skyler Davenport

Isaac's Man

Clint James

Creepy Girl

Camden Flowers

Boston Militia

Michael P Gardner

Egyptian Executioner

Marcus Graves

Dead Petrus

Matthew R. Staley

Stephen

Braden Fitzgerald

Elder Witch 1

Jennifer Griffin

Militia

Jim Henry

Annie the Whore

Katie Gunderson

Townsperson

Gary Teague

Chicken Thief

Toby Nichols

Militia Man

Luke Sexton

Demon

Michael Robert Brandon

Clothed dead body in the Crag

Michele B. McGraw

Chicken Plucker

Lindsey Roberts