Pete

Mark Duplass

Kevin

Steve Rannazzisi

Ruxin

Nick Kroll

Andre

Paul Scheer

Taco

Jon Lajoie

Jenny

Katie Aselton

Lindsey

Lindsay Sloane

Meegan

Leslie Bibb

Brooke

Lake Bell

Twyla

Frances Callier

Guest Star

Nadine Velazquez

Rafi

Jason Mantzoukas

Ellie

Alina Foley

Judge Humphrey

Stacey Travis

Ed

Michael Hitchcock

April

Alia Shawkat

Ryan

Cameron Bender

Waitress

Desi Lydic

Shiva

Janina Gavankar

Dr. Maxwell

Brandon Johnson

Bill Haddock / Bill

Seth Morris

Russell / Dr. Deramo

Rob Huebel

Jaywalking Girl

Carlson Young

Darcy

Alison Becker

Ambrosia

Janet Montgomery

Himself

John Hansen

Guest Star

Martin Starr

Security Line Woman

Lucille Soong

Randall

Affion Crockett

Das Dinga

Kristi Clainos

Collin

Will Shadley

Taco's Notary Girl

Trisha LaFache

Lanie

Shoshana Bush

Stacy

Elizabeth Wright Shapiro

Craig O'Connor

Craig Bierko

Molly

Molly Schade

Mr. Mitchell

Aaron Lustig

Lily

Brooke Nevin

Petting Zoo Owner

Ken Tipton

Guest Star

Ike Barinholtz

Ted

Jamey Sheridan

Angry Husband

Tony Daly

Cop

Colton Dunn

Himself

Chad Ochocinco

Himself

Josh Cribbs

Brassy Judge

Benton Jennings

Guest Star

Kaycee Stroh

Himself

Terrell Suggs

Tracy

Tracy Rannazzisi

Bailiff

Edward James Gage

Elevator Girl

Krista Kalmus

Guest Star

Rick Irwin

Dirty Randy / Dirty Randy (voice)

Seth Rogen

Trixie Von Stein

Jayma Mays

Baby Geoffrey

Adam Karchmer

Bethesda

Rob Riggle

Chalupa Batman

Jason David

Ted

Adam Brody