Michelle McNamara

Michelle McNamara

Lucille Miller

Tiffany Baker

Charlie Schmid

Aaron Dalla Villa

Candy Mossler

Tiffan Borelli

Ruby McCollum

Christine Osuala

Kitty Genovese

Aurora Heimbach

Charles Whitman

Brandon Scott Hughes

Stephanie Bryan

Verity Azario

Bobby Greenlease

Maxwell James

Gretchen Fritz

Betsey Brown

Melvin Powers

Tyler Cook

Gordon 'Cork' Miller

Tom Ashton

James Zeiss

Carl Hall

Rick Apicella

Dr. C. Leroy Adams

Gian Carlo Durland

Winston Moseley

Clinton Faulkner

Kathy Whitman

Lani Harms

Burton Abbott

Jeff Gonzalez

Kurt Grube

Kurt Grube

Jacques Mossler

Tony Dadika

Sophie Farrar

Athena Masci

Son in airport / Chip Sheppard

Chase Anderson

Sam McCollum

Douglas Robbs

Mary French

Tess Howsam

Bonnie Heady

Misha Calvert

Elsie Abbott

Catherine Oberg

Officer Houston McCoy

Brett Michael Davenport

Debra Miller

Siobhan Kiernan

Damir Mrkulic

Damir Mrkulic

Arthwell Hayton

Tyler Evans

John Hager

Noah Lee Margetts

Karl Ross

Michael Lester

Detective Hutchins

Jeffrey Parrillo

Detective Evans

Jeffrey Brewer

Officer Ramiro Martinez

Aldo Uribe

Releford McGriff

Michael Everett Johnson

Richie Bruns

Joseph Reiver

Housekeeper / Catalyst Patron

Sashia Dumont

Vincent Yacovelli

Vincent Yacovelli

Mary Ann Zielonko

Caitlin Mehner

Ed Montgomery

Pat Dwyer

Neighbor kid

Henry Gagliardi

Billy Mulvey

Matt McAllister

Lucy Brown

Dawn Adams

Margaret Whitman

Yvonne Cole

John Saunders

Scott Charles Jr.

Ron Miler

Addison Homs

Lou Shoulders

Charles F. Wagner IV

Allen Crum

Yaron Urbas

Georgia Abbott

Ardis Barrow

Frank Cannon

Mike Sutton

Rita Mossler

Rebecca Krainik

Detective Carroll

Christopher Spurrier

Alleen Rowe

Rachel Helen Pirarad

Guy Miller

Sean William Dougherty

Virginia Greenlease

Christina Delaine

Mack's Mom

Katrine Hoyt

Narrator (voice)

Nyahale Allie

Detective Sang

Jasson Finney

Roscoe Brown

Anthony Aroya

Robert Greenlease

Lee Bergman

Officer Jerry Day

Cory Boughton

Detective Patterson

Ronald Morehead

Keith Black

Greg Schweers

Wendy Fritz

Hayley Gunning

Otto Dezman

Eddie Smucygz

Alleen Rowe

Rachel Pirard

Mary Bryan

Joan Jubett

Harold Musgrove

Delano Montgomery

Percy Foreman

Stan Buturla

Detective John Tartaglia

Craig Thomas Rivela

Officer Milton Shoquist

Jon L. Peacock

Elaine Hayton

Susan Courtney

Sister Morand

Christina Toth

Amelia Snyder (12)

Alyssa Marvin

Mrs. Swenson

Susan Brooks

Dr. Charles Bryan

Keith O'Brien

Joseph Fink

Brandon deSpain

Bill Rose

Mark Ryan Anderson

Mrs. Fritz

Thea McCartan

William Ledterman

Frank Kelly

Vincent Caltagirone

Jeffrey C. Wolf

Kay McCollum

Vivica Johnson

Robert Boyer

Evan Enslow

Sonya McCollum

Milan Williams

Peggy Fletcher

Carol Jacobanis

Mr. Fritz

Dan Brennan

J. Frank Coakley, DA

William Otterson

Robert Mozer

Phil Simone

Detective Gregory

Michael Lewis Smith

Detective Bennett

Jason Lawergren

Snack Nerd

Corey Militzok

Hotel Clerk

Justin Andrew Davis

Narrator

Sunny Edelman

Danny Mossler

Bryan Frasca

Loretta McCollum

Ayelet Spence

Andre Picq

Julia Johnston

Detective Kidd

Samuel Shurtleff

Detective Robles

Rob Figueroa

Professor Kirk

Andy Baldeschwiler