Michelle McNamara
Michelle McNamara
Deputy Andrews
William J. Allgood
Roseann Quinn
Meghan E. Jones
Betty Williams
Tess Howsam
Nellie Madison
Sarah Kraus
Dr. Sam Sheppard
Tim Moriarty
Chester Burge
Anthony R. Foggia
Mary Gedeon
Julia Beach
Richard Speck
Benjamin Bass
Deputy Andrews
William J. Allgood
Gayle
Angelica Reeve
James Zeiss
Marilyn Sheppard
Airen DeLaMater
Mr. Buckson
Robin F. Baker
John Wayne Wilson
Steven Bono Jr.
Eric Madison
Perryn Pomatto
Mary Burge
Marian Edmiston
Joe Kudner
Jose Cagigal
Merlita Gargullo
Leanne Cabrera
Kurt Grube
Kurt Grube
Fritz Phillips Jr.
Dylan Wittrock
Detective Schottke
Collin Ware
Detective O'Grady
Rick Apicella
Deputy Rigby
Cory Boughton
Officer Bobby McAlpine
Will Gallacher
Georgia Madison
Dominique Johnson
William Martin
Joe Casey
Damir Mrkulic
Damir Mrkulic
Detective John Whalen
Nicholas M. Garofolo
Mrs. Rhinehart
Denise Crisci
Detective Flannagan
Lucas Atkins
Detective Fred Johnson
Dan Dobransky
Joseph Ryan
Michael Bauer
Detective Garreau
Thomas J. Lombardo
Jessie Mae Holland
Rachel Ann Jerome
Officer D'Angelo
Samuel Difiore
Vincent Yacovelli
Vincent Yacovelli
Plain clothes Detective
George V. Andreakos
Tommy Martin
Jimmy Dalton
Steve Resnick
Vasile Flutur
Mack Herring
Thom Niemann
Belle Bradley
Christine Donnelly
F. Lee Bailey
Brendan Reardon
R. Lee Davidson
William Jousset
Frank Byrnes
Troy Gochenour
Deputy Port Agent William Olsen
Patrick K. Dooley
Young Daughter
Monica Arsenault
Captain William Bright
Shawn Parr
Detective Frank Lanneau
Geoffrey Hillback
Monroe Parris
Brian Colin Foley
Freddie Watson
Phil John
Ike Nail
Scott Mandel
Richard Eberling (Younger)
Cameron DelGrosso
Ethel Kudner
Claire Jamison
Lieutenant Emile Giese
Dan Faber
Detective Harry Harris
Scott Watson
Gracie Buckson
Ashley Dior Jones
Kenny
Howard Weintraub
Officer Ratledge
James Feuer
Mr. Williams
John William Watkins
Aggie Underwood
Misha Calvert
Richard Eberling (Older)
Robert Blake
Bobby Flowers
Max Lebow
Narrator
Emily Fleischer
Mrs. Williams
Elise Rovinsky
Sgt. Michael Clancy
Matt Giroveanu
Detective James
Robert Lyons
Narrator
Ardis Barrow
Dr. Paul Kirk
David K. Conklin
Gilbert
John Hartzell
Stephen Butter
Patrick E. McCarthy
Officer Clarence Shuey
Daniel Jordano
Chaz
Greg Nutcher
Stephen Sheppard
Bradley W. Anderson
Louis
Douglas Robbs
Mike Ware
Seth Clayton
Commissioner Valentine
Larry Mihlon
Bill Rose
Mark Ryan Anderson
Lee Roy Martin
Joshua Price
Coroner Gerber
Mike Sutton
Gene
Roy Shuler
Detective Martin Gilwen
Ronald Morehead
Sgt. Hughie Granahan
Zach McNally
Joseph Gedeon
Hugh Scully
Detective Riley
Keith Rodriguez
Warren Burnett
Tom Waclawik
Chief Easton
Raymond Kelly
Tommy Bush
Phil Gillen
Mandy Ann Jordan
Olivia Nice
Narrator
Evelyn Maria Dia
Dr. Grice
Keith O'Brien
Robert Irwin
Gianmarco Soresi
Detective Grabowski
Cain Perry
Dr. John Campbell
Kevin D. McGee
Nina Jo Schmale
Brooke Norris
Mourner
Julie Chapin
Henrietta
Noelle Stewart
Judge Olsen
Sheldon Stone
Richard Sheppard Jr
Jason Paul Tate
Mrs. Burges Lawyer
Robert J. Gilman
Detective Jack Wallenda
Richard O'Brien
Betty
Marissa Rose Gordon
Richard Sheppard Sr
Diodato Grisi
Anthony Rocco
Jordan Theodore
Susanne Parris
Cassie Post
Married Woman
Jenna Ciralli
Detective Charlie McGowan
Roger Wayne
Judge Blythin
Joel Haberli
Sherry Martin
Samantha Smedley
Pamela Wilkening
Claudine Quadrat
Young Daughter
Samantha Clark
Narrator
Rebecca Spiro
Corrigan
Quinn Kronen
Officer Daniel Kelly
Steven M. Robertson
Narrator
Rebecca Knowles
Ethel Sheppard
Kathryn Hahner
Dr. Leroy Smith
Ben Sterling
Patricia Matusek
Jasmine Stiefel
Prosecutor Parrino
Paul Saltzberg
Tommy Martin
Jimmy Dalton
Chip Sheppard
Chase Anderson
George Murtaugh
Jeffrey Turboff
Local
Andrew Dolan
Lawrence Martin
Lawrence Derx
Detective Harrison
Michael Valentino
Cora Amurao
Anna Weng
John Mahon Prosecuting Attorney
Allen Enlow
Nancy Ahern
Alisha Spielmann
Valentia Pasion
Sook Hyung Yang
Narrator
Isabel Lodge
Lee Roy's Child
Adison Eisenberg