Michelle McNamara

Michelle McNamara

Deputy Andrews

William J. Allgood

Roseann Quinn

Meghan E. Jones

Betty Williams

Tess Howsam

Nellie Madison

Sarah Kraus

Dr. Sam Sheppard

Tim Moriarty

Chester Burge

Anthony R. Foggia

Mary Gedeon

Julia Beach

Richard Speck

Benjamin Bass

Deputy Andrews

William J. Allgood

Gayle

Angelica Reeve

James Zeiss

Marilyn Sheppard

Airen DeLaMater

Mr. Buckson

Robin F. Baker

John Wayne Wilson

Steven Bono Jr.

Eric Madison

Perryn Pomatto

Mary Burge

Marian Edmiston

Joe Kudner

Jose Cagigal

Merlita Gargullo

Leanne Cabrera

Kurt Grube

Kurt Grube

Fritz Phillips Jr.

Dylan Wittrock

Detective Schottke

Collin Ware

Detective O'Grady

Rick Apicella

Deputy Rigby

Cory Boughton

Officer Bobby McAlpine

Will Gallacher

Georgia Madison

Dominique Johnson

William Martin

Joe Casey

Damir Mrkulic

Damir Mrkulic

Detective John Whalen

Nicholas M. Garofolo

Mrs. Rhinehart

Denise Crisci

Detective Flannagan

Lucas Atkins

Detective Fred Johnson

Dan Dobransky

Joseph Ryan

Michael Bauer

Detective Garreau

Thomas J. Lombardo

Jessie Mae Holland

Rachel Ann Jerome

Officer D'Angelo

Samuel Difiore

Vincent Yacovelli

Vincent Yacovelli

Plain clothes Detective

George V. Andreakos

Tommy Martin

Jimmy Dalton

Steve Resnick

Vasile Flutur

Mack Herring

Thom Niemann

Belle Bradley

Christine Donnelly

F. Lee Bailey

Brendan Reardon

R. Lee Davidson

William Jousset

Frank Byrnes

Troy Gochenour

Deputy Port Agent William Olsen

Patrick K. Dooley

Young Daughter

Monica Arsenault

Captain William Bright

Shawn Parr

Detective Frank Lanneau

Geoffrey Hillback

Monroe Parris

Brian Colin Foley

Freddie Watson

Phil John

Ike Nail

Scott Mandel

Richard Eberling (Younger)

Cameron DelGrosso

Ethel Kudner

Claire Jamison

Lieutenant Emile Giese

Dan Faber

Detective Harry Harris

Scott Watson

Gracie Buckson

Ashley Dior Jones

Kenny

Howard Weintraub

Officer Ratledge

James Feuer

Mr. Williams

John William Watkins

Aggie Underwood

Misha Calvert

Richard Eberling (Older)

Robert Blake

Bobby Flowers

Max Lebow

Narrator

Emily Fleischer

Mrs. Williams

Elise Rovinsky

Sgt. Michael Clancy

Matt Giroveanu

Detective James

Robert Lyons

Narrator

Ardis Barrow

Dr. Paul Kirk

David K. Conklin

Gilbert

John Hartzell

Stephen Butter

Patrick E. McCarthy

Officer Clarence Shuey

Daniel Jordano

Chaz

Greg Nutcher

Stephen Sheppard

Bradley W. Anderson

Louis

Douglas Robbs

Mike Ware

Seth Clayton

Commissioner Valentine

Larry Mihlon

Bill Rose

Mark Ryan Anderson

Lee Roy Martin

Joshua Price

Coroner Gerber

Mike Sutton

Gene

Roy Shuler

Detective Martin Gilwen

Ronald Morehead

Sgt. Hughie Granahan

Zach McNally

Joseph Gedeon

Hugh Scully

Detective Riley

Keith Rodriguez

Warren Burnett

Tom Waclawik

Chief Easton

Raymond Kelly

Tommy Bush

Phil Gillen

Mandy Ann Jordan

Olivia Nice

Narrator

Evelyn Maria Dia

Dr. Grice

Keith O'Brien

Robert Irwin

Gianmarco Soresi

Detective Grabowski

Cain Perry

Dr. John Campbell

Kevin D. McGee

Nina Jo Schmale

Brooke Norris

Mourner

Julie Chapin

Henrietta

Noelle Stewart

Judge Olsen

Sheldon Stone

Richard Sheppard Jr

Jason Paul Tate

Mrs. Burges Lawyer

Robert J. Gilman

Detective Jack Wallenda

Richard O'Brien

Betty

Marissa Rose Gordon

Richard Sheppard Sr

Diodato Grisi

Anthony Rocco

Jordan Theodore

Susanne Parris

Cassie Post

Married Woman

Jenna Ciralli

Detective Charlie McGowan

Roger Wayne

Judge Blythin

Joel Haberli

Sherry Martin

Samantha Smedley

Pamela Wilkening

Claudine Quadrat

Young Daughter

Samantha Clark

Narrator

Rebecca Spiro

Corrigan

Quinn Kronen

Officer Daniel Kelly

Steven M. Robertson

Narrator

Rebecca Knowles

Ethel Sheppard

Kathryn Hahner

Dr. Leroy Smith

Ben Sterling

Patricia Matusek

Jasmine Stiefel

Prosecutor Parrino

Paul Saltzberg

Tommy Martin

Jimmy Dalton

Chip Sheppard

Chase Anderson

George Murtaugh

Jeffrey Turboff

Local

Andrew Dolan

Lawrence Martin

Lawrence Derx

Detective Harrison

Michael Valentino

Cora Amurao

Anna Weng

John Mahon Prosecuting Attorney

Allen Enlow

Nancy Ahern

Alisha Spielmann

Valentia Pasion

Sook Hyung Yang

Narrator

Isabel Lodge

Lee Roy's Child

Adison Eisenberg

Director

Jeremiah Crowell

Director

Nicholas McCarthy