Michelle McNamara

Michelle McNamara

Alice Crimmins

Airen DeLaMater

Emily

Caitlin Cassidy

Judge White

Jeffrey Alan

Gloria

Dawn Collet

Princess Marina Torlonia

Brandi Bravo

John Norman Collins

Nick Adamson

James Zeiss

Eddie Crimmins, Sr.

Alexander Kollar

Robles

Samuel Centrella

James Yenser

Rick Apicella

Daisy

Diana Craig

Joan Schell

Ardis Barrow

Duchess of Windsor

Alanna Davis

Kurt Grube

Kurt Grube

Son in airport / Chip Sheppard

Chase Anderson

George Whitmore Jr.

Donald Dash

Eddie Crimmins Jr.

Harris Brodsky

Crown A Employee

Mallory Goodman

Elsie Woodward

Betty Leigh

Joan Goshe

Patricia Bartlett

Damir Mrkulic

Damir Mrkulic

Patricia

Jessica DiGiovanni

Missy Crimmins

Henna Muric

Aron Bederson

FBI Agent

Matthew Hardy

William Woodward, Sr.

Larry Mihlon

Rhonda

Caitlin Cardile

Housekeeper / Catalyst Patron

Sashia Dumont

Vincent Yacovelli

Vincent Yacovelli

Truman Capote

Nathan Myers

Neighbor kid

Henry Gagliardi

Tony Grace

Lou Mastantuono

Janice

Alicia Henry

Zack Beyer

Jack Graham

Carter Hudson

Dale Schultz

Devin Doyle

Bulger

Kevin Kenny

Joe Rorech

Bryan Essing

Jim Bonaski

Lulu Lloyd

Misha Calvert

Misha Calvert

Ann Woodward

Vanna Pilgrim

Mary Flezsar

Erica Hernandez

Mack's Mom

Katrine Hoyt

Helen

Marianne Miller

Narrator (voice)

Nyahale Allie

Nathan Delaney

Rob Morgan

Jerry Piering

Bristol Pomeroy

Sheriff Kirk

Dan Brennan

Mrs. Livingston

Rachel Rear

Doug Harvey

John William Larkin

Joe Peel

Edward Campbell

Roy K. Moore

Drew Moore

David Leik

Scott Lehman

Detective Martin

Jimmie James

Max Wylie

William Otterson

Billy Woodward, Jr.

Kurt Smith

Amelia Snyder (12)

Alyssa Marvin

Webb Burke

Eric Purcell

Bill Rose

Mark Ryan Anderson

Nino Ascencio

Mr. Livingston

David Stam

Isobel Wylie

Charmaine Reedy

Secretary

Caroline Christi

Officer Matthewson

Thomas J. Lombardo

Sophie

Myla Beth

Elba

Suni Reyes

Hazar Atay

Trapper Nelson

David James Christine

Gwenevere Sisco

Karen Sue Beineman

Kerri Sohn

Snack Nerd

Corey Militzok

Hotel Clerk

Justin Andrew Davis

Thomas Bradshaw

Gerald

Joe Belknap

Margaret

Erica Genereux Smith

Jaime Collins

Surveyor

George Adamo

Detective Campbell

Greg Balla

Detective

Chris Adams

Danielle Brewer

Bruce Conner

Cavanaugh

Gregory Adair

Johnny

Bohdan Kostyk

Ryan Cummins

Neighbor

William Andrew Brewer

Puerto Rican Daughter

Mayra Amaya

Dawn Basom

Amelia Parker

Rose Younge Male Friend

James Y Camacho

April Andres

Irina Brovina

Jean Asprea

Mrs. Leik

Karen Ventosa

Pierre Candra

Jack Aviad

Jeff Deglow

Nicholas Barone

Matt Cantrell

Ludie Montgomery

Crystal Blake