Dave Rose

Zachary Knighton

Jane

Eliza Coupe

Alex Kerkovich

Elisha Cuthbert

Penny Hartz

Casey Wilson

Max

Adam Pally

Brad

Damon Wayans Jr.

Himself

Lance Briggs

Roy

Andy Richter

Brooke

Stephanie March

Daphne Wilson

Mary Elizabeth Ellis

Suzanne

Rachael Harris

Ben

Billy Beck

Chase

Mark-Paul Gosselaar

Big Dave

Michael McKean

Winnie McCray

Laura Catalina Ortiz

Fishmonger

Marc Evan Jackson

Andrew

Andrew Friedman

Derrick

Stephen Guarino

Katie

Abby Elliott

KrisJahn

RuPaul Charles

Chris

Brian Austin Green

Jake Umansky

Paxton Anderson

Terry Chuckles

David Alan Grier

Mr. Logan

Robert Picardo

Elliot

James Lesure

Dragga

Bergen Williams

Butcher

Brad Grunberg

Pete

Nick Zano

Josh Jill

Drew Droege

Kent

Matthew Del Negro

Lon 'The Car Czar' Sarofsky

Rob Corddry

Thief

John Gemberling

Dana hartz

Megan Mullally

Kevin

Matt Braunger

Jamie

Tom Christensen

Brandon

Rafi Silver

Guy

Chris Marrs

Radio DJ

Jason Berger

Ryan

Briga Heelan

Kid

Brandon Klopot

Mr. Kerkovich

Christopher McDonald

Clay

Jeff Howard

Pilgrim Man

Kelly Connell

Magic Ann

Rose Abdoo

Officer Sommers

Chris Williams

Connie

Regan Burns

Duckie Blenkinship

Matt Walsh

Marcus

Justin Louis Baldoni

Greg

Brian Maillard

Manny Petty

Edward Kiniry-Ostro

Martin

Kyle Red Silverstein

Thug

Colton Dunn

Brody Daniels

Jon Daly

Julian

Branton Box

Kyle

Andy Shephard

Shaun

Andy Gala

Cody

Brody Moller

Larry

Nate Shelkey

Shop Lady

Kelly Jenrette

Mrs. Kerkovich

Julie Hagerty

Gary

Fred Stoller

Major Fitness

Christopher Michael

Female Customer

Ellie Knaus

Pilgrim Woman

Amanda Carlin

Nana

Irene Roseen

The Brazilian

Danny Mora

Andrew

Aalok Mehta

Female Customer

Meredith Roberts

Cousin Ann

Sally Ann Brooks

Green Monkey

Scott Prendergast

Customer

Justin Dray

Bar Patron

Julie Goldman

Scotty

Seth Morris

Karissa

Laura Chinn

Nicole

Kulap Vilaysack

Trish

Jackie Clarke

Leslie Gruff

Nadege August

Store Owner

Janell Winkler

Paul

James Eason

Server

Lauren Howard Brown

Jimmy Nichols

Brady Ellis

marcy

Erin Pineda

Young Dave

Kailan Whitaker

Norman

Mike Still

Cousin Sherry

Suanne Spoke

Repo Man 1

Bruno Amato

Guy

Robert Bagnell

Crossing Guard

Jerry Hauck

Wilson

Alex Quijano

Candice

Chelsey Crisp

Brad's Boss

Ross Mackenzie

Waiter

Kenzo Lee

Jimmy

Matthew Nicklaw

Young Penny

Katie Silverman

Cute Guy

Jon Barinholtz

Jenny

Marissa Strickland

Waitress

Nichole Bunch

Sushi Lady

Nikki McKenzie

Cousin Terry

Christopher Darga

Ted

Patrick O'Sullivan