Alex

Elisha Cuthbert

Dave Rose

Zachary Knighton

Jane

Eliza Coupe

Penny Hartz

Casey Wilson

Max Blum

Adam Pally

Brad

Damon Wayans Jr.

Bouncer

Ian Roberts

Franklin

Kevin Christy

Francis Williams

Damon Wayans

Doug Hitler

Greg Cromer

Andrea

Courtney Henggeler

Bo Bazinski

Travis Van Winkle

Barbara

Meagan Fay

Alan Fitzgerald

Rob Huebel

Jason Shershow

T.J. Miller

Adrian

O-T Fagbenle

Carl

Brett Gelman

Big Woman

Jen Kober

Jackie

Mikaela Hoover

Atticus

Sergio Cilli

Biker

Alex Mooren

Howard Blum

Alan Rachins

Instructor

Nancy Sinclair

Black Guy

Amad Jackson

Pete

Nick Zano

Tim

David Storrs

Todd

Ryan Sypek

Avi

Paul Scheer

Melinda Shershow

June Raphael

Brody Daniels

Jon Daly

Hipster Girl

Cheryl Texiera

Clark

Jim Hazelton

Boy

Cade Dundish

Dianne

Danielle Schneider

Doctor

Nelson Mashita

Miss Mary

Patricia Forte

Derrick

Stephen Guarino

Ellen

Heather Fox

Connor

Justin Wilczynski

Carla

April Wade

Hooper

Dave Bushnell

Chelsea

Caitlin Thompson

Hardware Store Owner

Donn Carl Harper

Royston Summers

Greg Magnuson

Pailine Blum

Caroline Aaron

Kim

Bre Blair

Fireman

Elimu Nelson

Bo's Mom

Roz Witt

Malcolm

Michael Mosley

Ione

Devin Sidell

Ian

Max Greenfield

Customer

Justin Dray

Scotty

Seth Morris

Tommy

Nick Thune

Roger

Nathan Barnatt

Yoni

Gil Ozeri

Waitress

Angelique Cabral

Grandma Nellie

Cynthia Frost

Restaurant Investor

Alex Morris

Paul

Clint Culp

Chef Leslie

Nat Faxon

Dr. Charles

Brian Huskey

Dana Hartz

Megan Mullally

Mossimo

Alex Valente

Waiter

Matthew Rocheleau

Tiffani

Alex Mauriello

Trish

Rachel Germaine

Preston

Jonathan Emerson

Cop

Mike Hagerty

Rita

Gina Rodriguez

Toby

John Bobek

Normal Guy 2

Curtis Gwinn

Zane

James Kirkland

Guy

Scott Golden

Umpire / Manager / Bartender

Billy Merritt

Kevin

Michael Weaver

John

Michael Rady

Samantha

Nikki McCauley

Grant

James Wolk

Zombie Co-Worker

Olivia May

Normal Guy 1

Rob Kerkovich

Young Alex

Isabella Cramp

Minister

Anthony Johnson

Car Czar

Rob Corddry

Normal Guy 3

David Gueriera

Bachelor

Gabriel Myers

Young Jane

Daisy Stoneman

Randy

B.J. Bales

Tyler the Parrot (voice)

Tom Kenny

Robert

Michael Daniel Cassady

Chris

Brian Austin Green

Daphne Wilson

Mary Elizabeth Ellis

Sara

Pilar Holland